Term
Are there incapacity defenses for intentional torts?
|
|
Definition
|
|
Term
|
Definition
1. Harmful or offensive contact
2. with the plaintiff's person
3. intent
4. causation
|
|
|
Term
What is the test for offensive contact (battery)? |
|
Definition
Objective Test:
unpermitted by a person of ordinary sensitivity (offends sensibilities of a reasonable person)
i.e. unwelcome sexual contact |
|
|
Term
What is a plaintiff's person for purposes of battery? |
|
Definition
anything the plaintiff is holding or touching |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
1. Must place plaintiff in reasonable apprehension
2. of an immediate battery
3. intent
4. causation
(words alone insufficient) |
|
|
Term
Apprehension in an assault case |
|
Definition
Knowledge
(only assault if plaintiff sees it coming) |
|
|
Term
threat of immediate battery for assault |
|
Definition
Words alone lack immediacy (must be accompanied by physical conduct)
words can negate immediacy (especially if conditional) |
|
|
Term
Elements of False Imprisonment |
|
Definition
1. Act of restraint by the defendant
2. that keeps plaintiff confined in a bounded area
3. intent
4. causation |
|
|
Term
What counts as an act of restraint by the defendant for purposes of false imprisonment? |
|
Definition
threats (that would threaten reasonable person), omission if there was pre-existing duty
Examples: physical barriers, physical force, threats of force, failure to release, invalid use of legal authority
*plaintiff must know about the restraint or be harmed
*moral pressure and future threats insufficient
|
|
|
Term
What counts as confinement in a bounded area for purposes of false imprisonment? |
|
Definition
No reasonable means of escape that plaintiff can reasonably discover |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
1. an act by defendant amounting to extreme outrageous conduct
2. severe emotional distress (DAMAGES)
3. intent OR recklessness
4. causation
|
|
|
Term
Outrageous conduct for IIED? |
|
Definition
"Exceeds all bounds of decency tolerated in a civil society"
Hallmarks of outrageousness:
continuous or repetetive, common carrior to guests, plaintiff fragile (children, elderly, pregnant women)
Extreme sensitivies do not matter UNLESS defendant knew about them in advance |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
name calling, exercise of first amendment rights |
|
|
Term
Emotional distress for the purposes of IIED |
|
Definition
Subjective element to be determined by jury (no physical manifestations required) |
|
|
Term
Elements of tresspass to land |
|
Definition
1. physical invasion of land
2. that inferfere's with plaintiff's possession
3. intent
4. causation
plaintiff = possessor NOT owner |
|
|
Term
physical invasian (tresspass on land) |
|
Definition
going onto the property, throwing something tangible onto the property
defendant need not be aware that he has crossed a boundary line |
|
|
Term
Elements of Tresspass to Chattel/Conversion |
|
Definition
1. Interference with right to possession of tangible personal property (damage, stealing)
2. intent
3. causation
4. damages for tresspass to chattles
*interference may be damaging chattel or depriving plaintiff his lawful right of possesssion |
|
|
Term
Difference between tresspass to chattel/conversion |
|
Definition
amount of interference
small interference: tresspass to chattel
significant interference: conversion (conversion can include wrongful transfer, wrongful detention, and substantially changing)
*will be conversion when the interference is so serious that it warrant requiring D to pay chattel's full value |
|
|
Term
what does conversion plaintiff recover? |
|
Definition
not JUST cost of repair but full market value of item (forced sale) |
|
|
Term
what does trespass to chattel plaintiff recover? |
|
Definition
|
|
Term
New York Conversion/Trespass to chattel |
|
Definition
expanded to electronic records |
|
|
Term
ELEMENTS OF AN INTENTIONAL TORT - to establish prima facie case (in general) |
|
Definition
1. ACT (volitional movement by defendant)
2. Intent (specific or general - as long as actor knows with substantial certainty that these consequences will result)
3. Causation
|
|
|
Term
|
Definition
When defendant intends to commit a tort BUT instead:
1. commits a different tort against that person
2. commits the tort against a different person
3. commits a different tort against a different person
|
|
|
Term
Transferred intent ONLY works for the following torts (must be BOTH tort intended and tort committed) : |
|
Definition
assault
battery
false imprisonment
tresspass to land OR
tresspass to chattels |
|
|
Term
Intentional Torts that Require Showing of Damages |
|
Definition
1. IIED (severe emotional distress)
2. Tresspass to Chattels (actual damages - at least to a possessory right) |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
intentional harm to third pesron and plaintiff suffers severe emotional distress because of it, P can show:
1. present when injury occured
2. close relative of injured person
3. defendant knew 1 and 2 |
|
|
Term
Affirmative Defenses to Intentional Torts |
|
Definition
1. Consent
2. Self Defense/Defense of Others/Defense of Property
3. Privilege of Arrest
4. Necessity |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
-only an individual with legal capacity can consent to a tort (youngsters and drunks lack legal capacity, but children can consent to age-appropriate tortious invasions)
*note: think about whether or not defendant exceeded the bounds of the consent |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
express declaration that grants defendant permissions to behave in tortious way (words)
void if obtained by fraud or duress |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
Consent implied from custom, or out of defendant's reasonable interpretation of plaintiff's objective conduct and other surrounding circumstances (body language) |
|
|
Term
Defense of Self/Others/Property |
|
Definition
D must show:
threat is imminent, reasonable belief that threat is genuine, response limited to proportional/necessary force (rule of symmetry)
deadly force not available to protect property
*IN NY you must retreat (if possible) before applying deadly force (unless you're in your home) |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
D invades P's property to protect the community as a whole or a significant group of people
No liability for property torts --> absolute defense |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
Defendant invades plaintiff's property in an emergency to protect an interest of his own
-must pay for any harm done to property (but not liable for nominal or punitive damages)
-P cannot throw D off his land as long as emergency continues (will be liable for harm) |
|
|