Shared Flashcard Set

Details

Torts: Intentional
intentional torts
33
Law
Graduate
05/20/2012

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term

Are there incapacity defenses for intentional torts?

Definition
No
Term
Elements of Battery
Definition

1. Harmful or offensive contact

2. with the plaintiff's person 

3. intent

4. causation 

Term
What is the test for offensive contact (battery)?
Definition

Objective Test: 

 

unpermitted by a person of ordinary sensitivity (offends sensibilities of a reasonable person)

 

i.e. unwelcome sexual contact

Term
What is a plaintiff's person for purposes of battery?
Definition
anything the plaintiff is holding or touching 
Term
Elements of Assault
Definition

1. Must place plaintiff in reasonable apprehension

2. of an immediate battery

3. intent

4. causation 

 

(words alone insufficient)

Term
Apprehension in an assault case
Definition

Knowledge

 

(only assault if plaintiff sees it coming)

Term
threat of immediate battery for assault
Definition

Words alone lack immediacy (must be accompanied by physical conduct)

 

words can negate immediacy (especially if conditional)

Term
Elements of False Imprisonment
Definition

1. Act of restraint by the defendant 

2. that keeps plaintiff confined in a bounded area 

3. intent

4. causation 

Term
What counts as an act of restraint by the defendant for purposes of false imprisonment?
Definition

threats (that would threaten reasonable person), omission if there was pre-existing duty

 

Examples: physical barriers, physical force, threats of force, failure to release, invalid use of legal authority

*plaintiff must know about the restraint or be harmed

 

*moral pressure and future threats insufficient

 

Term
What counts as confinement in a bounded area for purposes of false imprisonment?
Definition
No reasonable means of escape that plaintiff can reasonably discover 
Term
Elements of IIED
Definition

1. an act by defendant amounting to extreme outrageous conduct

2. severe emotional distress (DAMAGES)

3. intent OR recklessness 

4. causation


Term
Outrageous conduct for IIED?
Definition

"Exceeds all bounds of decency tolerated in a civil society"

 

Hallmarks of outrageousness:

continuous or repetetive, common carrior to guests, plaintiff fragile (children, elderly, pregnant women)

 

Extreme sensitivies do not matter UNLESS defendant knew about them in advance

Term
Not outrageous conduct
Definition
name calling, exercise of first amendment rights
Term
Emotional distress for the purposes of IIED
Definition
Subjective element to be determined by jury (no physical manifestations required)
Term
Elements of tresspass to land
Definition

1. physical invasion of land

2. that inferfere's with plaintiff's possession

3. intent

4. causation 

 

plaintiff = possessor NOT owner

Term
physical invasian (tresspass on land)
Definition

going onto the property, throwing something tangible onto the property

 

defendant need not be aware that he has crossed a boundary line

Term
Elements of Tresspass to Chattel/Conversion
Definition

1. Interference with right to possession of tangible personal property (damage, stealing)

2. intent

3. causation

4. damages for tresspass to chattles 

 

*interference may be damaging chattel or depriving plaintiff his lawful right of possesssion

Term
Difference between tresspass to chattel/conversion
Definition

amount of interference

 

small interference: tresspass to chattel

significant interference: conversion (conversion can include wrongful transfer, wrongful detention, and substantially changing) 

 

*will be conversion when the interference is so serious that it warrant requiring D to pay chattel's full value

Term
what does conversion plaintiff recover?
Definition
not JUST cost of repair but full market value of item (forced sale)
Term
what does trespass to chattel plaintiff recover?
Definition
cost of repair
Term
New York Conversion/Trespass to chattel
Definition
expanded to electronic records
Term
ELEMENTS OF AN INTENTIONAL TORT - to establish prima facie case (in general)
Definition

1. ACT (volitional movement by defendant)

2. Intent (specific or general - as long as actor knows with substantial certainty that these consequences will result)

3. Causation


Term
Transferred Intent 
Definition

When defendant intends to commit a tort BUT instead:

 

1. commits a different tort against that person

2. commits the tort against a different person 

3. commits a different tort against a different person 

 

Term
Transferred intent ONLY works for the following torts (must be BOTH tort intended and tort committed) : 
Definition

assault

battery

false imprisonment

tresspass to land OR

tresspass to chattels

Term
Intentional Torts that Require Showing of Damages
Definition

1. IIED (severe emotional distress)

2. Tresspass to Chattels (actual damages - at least to a possessory right) 

Term
IIED to bystander
Definition

intentional harm to third pesron and plaintiff suffers severe emotional distress because of it, P can show:

 

1. present when injury occured

2. close relative of injured person

3. defendant knew 1 and 2 

Term
Affirmative Defenses to Intentional Torts
Definition

1. Consent

2. Self Defense/Defense of Others/Defense of Property

3. Privilege of Arrest

4. Necessity

Term
Consent Defense 
Definition

-only an individual with legal capacity can consent to a tort  (youngsters and drunks lack legal capacity, but children can consent to age-appropriate tortious invasions)

 

*note: think about whether or not defendant exceeded the bounds of the consent 

Term
Express Consent
Definition

express declaration that grants defendant permissions to behave in tortious way (words)

 

void if obtained by fraud or duress

Term
Implied Consent
Definition
Consent implied from custom, or out of defendant's reasonable interpretation of plaintiff's objective conduct and other surrounding circumstances (body language)
Term
Defense of Self/Others/Property
Definition

D must show: 

 

threat is imminent, reasonable belief that threat is genuine, response limited to proportional/necessary force (rule of symmetry) 

deadly force not available to protect property

 

*IN NY you must retreat (if possible) before applying deadly force (unless you're in your home)

Term
Public Necessity
Definition

D invades P's property to protect the community as a whole or a significant group of people

 

No liability for property torts --> absolute defense 

Term
Private Necessity 
Definition

Defendant invades plaintiff's property in an emergency to protect an interest of his own

 

-must pay for any harm done to property (but not liable for nominal or punitive damages)

 

-P cannot throw D off his land as long as emergency continues (will be liable for harm)

Supporting users have an ad free experience!