Shared Flashcard Set

Details

Defences: Insanity, Automatism and Intoxication
Case law for criminal defence of insanity, automatism and intoxication
16
Law
Undergraduate 1
05/06/2013

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term
M'Naghten rules
Definition
Defect of the mind leading to a defect in reason, so the defendant doesn't know the nature or quality of his actions or that that the act is wrong
Term
Kemp
Definition
Physical conditions can constitute a disease of the mind so long as they cause a defect of reason
Term
Sullivan
Definition
If the effect of the disease is to impair mental facilities of reason, it does not matter whether or not the defect is mental or physical
Term
Quick
Definition
Hypoglaecemia (not enough blood sugar) was caused by external sources - not a disease of the mind
Term
Hennesy
Definition
Hyperglaecemia (too much blood sugar) - was caused by internal sources - a disease of the mind
Term
Rabey
Definition
Excessive reaction - psychological/emotional makeup - internal cause
Term
R v T
Definition
Post-traumatic stress disorder following a rape is external cause
Term
Burgess
Definition
Sleepwalking is an internal cause
Term
Windle
Definition
Wrong = legally wrong
Term
Hill v Baxter
Definition
Attacked by bees. Involuntary response by external sources.
Term
Broome
Definition
Automatism must be a TOTAL loss of control
Term
Bailey
Definition
Cannot avoid liability where a state of automatism is self-induced
Term
Hardie
Definition
Intoxication will be treated as involuntary if the prosecution cannot prove that D might realize what happened when he took it
Term
DPP v Beard
Definition
If a defendant is so intoxicated that he cannot form the requisite mens rea, he cannot be liable for a crime of specific intent
Term
Majewski
Definition
The D's intoxication supplies the mens rea for crimes of basic intent. TEST #1: An offence is one of specific intent if only intention will suffice for liability, and an offence is one of basic intent if recklessness suffices (Lord Simon). TEST #2:An offence is one of specific intent if a further intent is required (i.e. the mens rea extends beyond the actus reus), but if the mens rea and actus reus coincide, it is one of basic intent. (Lord Elwyn Jones).
Term
O'Grady
Definition
Cannot rely on intoxicated mistake for sexual offences (these will be considered crimes of basic intent)
Supporting users have an ad free experience!