Shared Flashcard Set

Details

Evidence Relevance and Speciallized Rules
GShep Spring 2011
15
Law
Graduate
04/26/2011

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term
Is character evidence generally available?
Definition
No
Term
What special situations allow for character evidence to prove past conduct?
Definition
  1. Criminal defendants
  2. Crime Victims (not rape victims)
  3. Evidence about witnesses for purposes of impeachment
  4. Sexual Assault Cases/Child Molest
  5. Character is an element of the crime/claim/defense
  6. Prior Bad Acts
  7. Habbit
Term
What are the rules for Character evidence about a criminal defendant?
Definition
  1. D is allowed to offer evedince of a pertinent trait of his own character.
  2. Prosecuter cannot be the first to introduce the evidence
  3. If d enters evidence about the victim, p can introduce evidence of the same trait in d.  (think violent aggressor is a self defense murder/assault case)
  4. Proof on direct must be reputation or opinion
  5. On cross specific instances allowed
Term

When is character evidence about the victim admissable?

 

Definition
  1. can be offered by the accused
  2. by the prosecution in rebuttal of the accused's evidence
  3. Must be proved by reputation or opinion
  4. may be rebutted by specific instances on cross
  5. Rape reverses the usual rules ***
Term
What are the FRE 412 Rape shield rules?
Definition
  1. D generally cannot enter evidence about the complainants past sexual behavior or predispostion.
  2. If it is to show another person was the source of the semen, injury, or other physical evidence.
  3. If v has slept with d before and consent is an issue.
  4. If it would violate the constitutional right to present a defense
  5. ONLY IN CIVIL CASES if otherwise admissible and the probative value substantially outweighs the danger of harm to the victim.
  6. Must serve notice at 14 days before the trial, cour conducts and incamera hearing on admissablility
Term
Can the prosecutor/plaintiff admit character evidence about the defendant in a sexual assault/molestation trial?
Definition
Yes, with advance notice
Term
When are prior bad acts admissable?
Definition

Not a complete list but proving...

  1. motive
  2. opportunity
  3. intent
  4. preperation
  5. plan
  6. knowledge
  7. identity
  8. absence of mistake or accident (i didn't mean to slit his throat)
  9. Modus Operandi
Term
What is habit evidence?
Definition

Evidence if particular behavior in a particular setting.

  1. always leaving the seat up
  2. always driving the same way to work
  3. proven by specific instances
Term
Are subsequent remedial measur permitted into evidence to prove negligence?
Definition

Not generally  esp. to prove negligence unless

  1. for impeachment
  2. feasibility in strict liability if d has denied it
  3. to prove ownership/control
Term
Are civil settlement offers and negotiaitons admissable?
Definition

Not generally as long as :

  1. they happened after the claim is advanced that the party has not conceded
  2. offers of settlement for undisputed claims can be admitted
  3. if the p is suing to enforce a settlement agreement
  4. settlements w/ a third party are not admissable as to the validity of the claim
  5. cannot be used for impeachment

Are admissable for:

  1. Proving bias
  2. Refuting claims of undue delay
Term
Offers to pay medical expenses in or out?
Definition
out. we want ot encourage good acts.
Term

Withdrawn pleas in or out?

 

Definition
Out
Term
Nolo Pleas in or out?
Definition
out
Term
Plea bargaining statements to police in or out?
Definition

In generally, but ask:

  • did the prosecutor give the police authority to plea bargain or did they act like they had authority? Out
  • was the miranda warning given? In
  • d can introduce it then p can go to town
Supporting users have an ad free experience!