Term
What is depression economics? |
|
Definition
Failure on the demand side of the economy (insufficient spending by consumers) has become a clear limit on prosperity for a large part of the world. For a long time the world had thought we had "tamed" the business cycle, but this is not the case. Krugman believes we are in a "liquidity trap". No one wants to lend money, despite the Feds best efforts. Krugman believes we need to increase the money supply to get cash flowing and consumption jumpstarted. |
|
|
Term
What is the shadow banking system and why is it important? |
|
Definition
The shadow banking system consists of non-depository institutions like money markey mutual funds and hedge funds that provide services similar to commercial banks. These institutions can be either the lender or the borrower, and they lend or borrow in order to satisfy a need for liquidity. The issue with this is that the shadow banking system is not regulated like commercial banks, leaving it vulnerable to things like bank panics. |
|
|
Term
Use ISLM analysis to show how fiscal stimulus can be used to cure a recession caused by inadequate demand. |
|
Definition
In a recession caused by inadequate demand, such as the prolonged and dramatic one we face globally today, fiscal stimulus can be used as a fairly effective tool to combat the issue. Fiscal stimulus involves the central bank of a country in recession flooding the system with currency (i.e. buying back T-bills from the public, thereby introducing more money into the system as a whole), which effectively shifts the LM curve of money (money supply) rightward in an expansion. With this increase in money supply, the real interest rate (y-axis, dependent variable) falls, and Y the real income / macro-speaking equivalent to GDP (x-axis, independent variable) rises. With this stimulus, the argument goes that because interest rates are low, the desire to save as opposed to consume also diminishes, thus sparking more and more people to begin using their money to consume goods (the first step in increasing demand). Following increased consumer expenditure comes an increase in wages, as firms begin making more money from sales, as well as a decrease in unemployment as those same firms hire more people to fill their orders; as more people begin to work for hire wages, they begin to spend more of their increases in income on consumption as opposed to saving it since the interest they would earn would not be very much, further driving up demand. Thus, the right amount of fiscal stimulus can, theoretically be used to break a demand-related recession. |
|
|
Term
How did Alan Greenspan allow and encourage the bubbles that grew during his tenure at the Fed to happen? |
|
Definition
|
|
Term
What was the Great Moderation? |
|
Definition
The Great Moderation was a reduction in the volatility of the business cycle starting in the mid-80's. It was caused by greater central bank independence, reduced gov't regulation & taxation, economic good luck. It has been argued that the greater predictability in economic and financial performance associated with the Great Moderation caused firms to hold less capital and be less concerned about liquidity positions, which may have helped contribute to the attitude of the financial sector that missed so many crucial indices that the subprime mortgage market was going to collapse. |
|
|
Term
Latin American Debt Crisis |
|
Definition
Mexico's first problem started with its infrastructure. It set up inward facing economic policy, where instead of importing goods from other countries it created institutions to create those products domestically, and set high tariffs on imports of similar goods produced abroad. This infrastructure became entrenched in the socio-economic structure. Then, in the 1970's, as the price of oil was shooting to record levels, there was a massive discovery of oil in Mexico. This brought massive amounts of foreign capital into Mexico, which spurred intense growth of firms. This in turn required more money, this time in the form of foreign loans, leading to a large debt in the form of U.S. dollars.
In July 1982, the Mexican gov't realized it wouldn't be able to pay its debts, and sent a delegation to the U.S. to inform the gov't that they were insolvent. This shattered the foreign confidence in Mexico and this loss of confidence spread to other Latin American countries that also carried debts in dollars. This led to a flight of foreign capital, leaving other Latin American countries insolvent as well, even the ones that were responsibly managed. |
|
|
Term
What is the trilemma that countries face when choosing their exchange rate? |
|
Definition
They can:
1. Stabilize Exchange Rate: Pegging a currency to another, or using the volatility of the exchange rate.
2. Capital Mobility:
3. Independent Monetary Policy: Process by which the monetary authority of a country can control the money supply.
A country can only choose 2 out of the 3, creating a trilemma |
|
|
Term
Krugman paints a picture in which developing countries in crisis are forced to choose between combating a recession (internal balance) or restoring international confidence in their economy (external balance). What is the basis of this dilemma and what are the tradeoffs? |
|
Definition
Developing countries may choose whether to cater to the "confidence fairy" agreeing to austerity measures prescribed by the international community, thus attempting to direct foreign capital flow back into the country, or to attempt to combat the recession internally by increasing the money supply or lowering interest rates. |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
Refers to a market process in which bad results occur when buyers and sellers have asymmetric information. In this market, the bad products are more likely to be selected. Used originally in insurance, those with a higher risk are more likely to purchase insurance than those with lower risk. |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
Repos are classified as a money-market instrument. They are usually used to raise short-term capital. It is a form of short-term borrowing for dealers in government securities. The dealer sells the government securities (T-bills, "informationally insensitive debt") to investors, usually on an overnight basis, and buys them back the following day. |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
A percentage that is subtracted from the market value of the repurchase. |
|
|
Term
Informationally Insensitive Debt |
|
Definition
Debt in which the value of the product does not depend on the amount of information available. |
|
|
Term
What was the role in the financial crisis of AIG? |
|
Definition
They were the main seller of CDS (credit default swaps) on CDOs. Therefore when housing prices stopped increasing and CDO's started defaulting AIG was insolvent because they couldn't pay out for the CDS's they had sold. |
|
|
Term
What was the role in the financial crisis of Goldman Sachs? |
|
Definition
Goldman Sachs would purchase en masse these subprime mortgages from loan originators, structure them into CDOs, get investment grade ratings from ratings agencies like S&P and Moody's, then market them as sound investments to conservative investors, like pension fund managers. Their risk analysis using their VAR models were based on incomplete data sets which resulted in artificially boosted predictions. Once they realized the CDOs were toxic, they frantically began buying CDSs to hedge themselves against their inevitable losses. Goldman Sachs and other Wall Street firms like it got paid for every CDO they produced, which led to an incentive to provide quantity over quality. Banker's bonuses were based on short term success, even though they were betting long. This rewarded quantity, not quality of CDO's. |
|
|
Term
What was the role in the financial crisis of the loan originators (LOs)? |
|
Definition
The loan originators were the people that made the initial home mortgage loans to people. They made loans to people with low teaser rates that eventually got jacked up to higher rates after two or three years. These low rates or easy access to money combined with people's desire to own a home inspired people to take out these loans through the LOs. The LOs obviously knew these people would not be able to pay the loans back, but they made a commission on every loan they sold, and could sell off the risk to Wall Street firms like Goldman Sachs that could repackage these subprime loans into gigantic and complex CDOs with AAA ratings, disguising the toxic assets that were inside. LOs stopped checking people for their credit history and didn't fill out the proper paperwork to give loans out since they assumed no risk by doing so. This was an extreme case of moral hazard. |
|
|
Term
What was the role in the financial crisis of the ratings agencies? |
|
Definition
The role of the ratings agencies in the financial disaster was mainly of giving CDO's artificially high investment-grade ratings. Reasons as to why this happened include the fact that there was a fiscal incentive for ratings agencies to give Wall Street firms favorable ratings. Ratings agencies are essentially service companies that only get paid upon completion of their service (providing a rating to a financial instrument presented by one of the firms). In a way, this made them subservient to the firms that they were supposed to be keeping an eye on. This created a moral dilemma for ratings agencies; giving them an excuse to not dig too deeply into what they were rating. |
|
|
Term
What was the role in the financial crisis of CDO's? |
|
Definition
The CDO (collateralized debt obligation) was a financial instrument contructed by Goldman Sachs and other Wall Street firms. These consisted of thousands of mortgage bonds, which in turn consisted of thousands of home mortgages. These were organized in various pools or tranches, with the top tranches being rated AAA by the ratings agencies. They also removed the lowest tranches of the CDOs and repackaged them into artificial CDOs (CDO^2). The problem with these was that there was no part of the CDO that was risk free, as a AAA rating would imply, and these were being marketed as risk free assets. This in turn was what caused the financial collapse; once people started defaulting on their mortgages, the CDOs started to collapse and the financial system went into a meltdown. |
|
|
Term
What was the role in the financial crisis of CDS's? |
|
Definition
CDS's (credit default swaps) were a financial instrument that acted as an insurance policy against the failure of CDO's. Lewis said it was like taking out a high-paying fire insurance policy on someone else's building when the building was already on fire. People that bought credit default swaps were betting against CDO's. If the CDO failed, the person that sold the CDS had to pay the person that bought it. Until then, CDS buyers paid a premium to the insurer.
They contributed to the current situation as follows. CDS allow credit creation for two reasons: protection sellers may be unregulated (don't have to put up capital against the risks they wirte) and where they are regulated, capital requirements against exposures can be lower, especially when the protection is written against very highly rated risk. Risk on mortgage pools got higher ratings because of faulty assumptions about individual borrower creditworthiness / house price movements / house price correlations.
So when house prices all collapsed together and borrowers walked away, protection sellers found they didn't have enough capital to cover the sharp, simultaneous increased likelihood of having to honour the contracts they'd written. Since everyone was the same way round, they couldn't lay off the risk. |
|
|
Term
How prepared was Lewis for working on Wall Street? How about other characters in the book? Did they have degrees in finance or any relevant field? |
|
Definition
Lewis states in the prologue that he had never taken an accounting course, never ran a business, and never even had a savings of his own to manage, and yet Wall Street hired him. Burry was a neurosurgeon. |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
Started in Thailand (1997-98). The huge trade imbalance and the disappointment in export revenues undermined investor's confidence in Thailand's ability to keep its exchange rate pegged to the dollar. People began expecting a devaluation and didn't want to be holding the Thai baht when it came. Also, much of the debt that Thailand was holding came from the international markets, and had to be paid back in dollars. This raised the cost of devaluation because Thai financial institutions raised revenue in baht, but owed a fixed amount of dollars. Any change in investor confidence could undermine the entire economy.
What is less certain is how the crisis spread to the rest of the Asian countries. One theory is that when investors started losing confidence in Thailand, they started looking at their other investments in the area and worrying about those. They thought that if Thailand could fall, why couldn't these other countries. Unfortunately, while this could have been avoided, there was a self fulfilling prophecy where investors lost confidence in Asian markets, thus engaging in capital flight to quality and actually causing the crisis that they feared was coming. |
|
|
Term
Provide a narrative and economic explanation for Greenspan's bubbles. Why did he allow them, and how did he encourage them? |
|
Definition
It started with businesses starting to figure out how to use information technology in the 90's. This lifted profits and helped control inflation, contributing to the good economic news under Greenspan. The Feds would normally raise interest rates to control bubbles and over-inflation. It is speculated that if employment goes below 5% there will be accelerated inflation, and therefore the normal reaction from the Fed would be to raise interest rates. Greenspan however refused to do so because "acceleration of productivity growth might have changed the historic relationship between low unemployment and accelerating inflation. He was right, unemployment fell to record levels and inflation remained normal.
Greenspan saw the stock bubble and warned against it but didn't do anything to curve it, instead he waited for the bubble to burst. He was worried about the possibility of "corrosive deflation" so he kept cutting rates, eventually bringing the Federal Funds rate to just 1 percent. When monetary policy didn't get traction, the housing market did. Greenspan ended up successfully replacing the stock bubble with the housing bubble. He did not believe a major decline in housing prices was likely. |
|
|
Term
How do mortgage bonds differ from corporate or government bonds? |
|
Definition
Government bonds are issued by the government, promising to pay a certain amount on a certain date, as well as periodic interest payments. Corporate bonds are issued by corporations, mortgage bonds are backed by a pool of mortgages on a real estate asset like houses. Government bonds (U.S.) are essentially riskless, as the government can simply print more money to pay off the debt. They have low interest rates. Corporate bonds have higher interest rates as the companies have the risk of going bankrupt. Mortgage bonds are dependent on the payments recieved by the homewoners every month. The risk with mortgage bonds is that homeowners will not be able to pay off their debt and will walk away from it, thus the owner of the bond will not receive payment. |
|
|
Term
What role(s) do Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac play in the mortgage market? |
|
Definition
Fannie and Freddie are Government Sponsored Enterprises (GSEs). This means they are privately owned, but receive support from the Federal Government, and assume some public responsibilities.
The GSEs provide a secondary market in home mortgages, puchasing mortgages from the lenders who originate them. As part of their public responsibility, they GSEs commit to purchase specified numbers of subprime loans, because without them, there would not be much subprime lending. This puts them at risk, and if they have a crisis like the one in 07-08, the taxpayer is on the hook to bail them out. |
|
|
Term
What are the barriers to entry for small firms like Cornwall Capital and individuals? |
|
Definition
The main barrier to entry is the amount of capital that they had. Wall Street didn't take a firm seriously unless they had $100 million minimum to qualify for an ISDA license, which would allow them to purchase CDSs. They are viewed as a small fish in a very large pond, and as such have a much harder time gaining access to the resources that large Wall Street firms have. They had inferior reputations. |
|
|
Term
What was Wing Chau's job? |
|
Definition
He was a CDO manager at Harding Advisory. |
|
|
Term
When the market for subprime mortgages and CDOs begins to unravel, bond ratings don't change at all. Why not? |
|
Definition
The issue is whether the seller of the CDS to Burry would recognize the non-performance of the CDOs that Burry bought insurance on. That is, Burry bought an insurance policy. The policy should pay up if the value of the asset declines. The seller of the policy does not want to pay up and so they refuse to recognize or acknowledge that the asset has declined in value. |
|
|
Term
|
Definition
A geographical region in which it would maximize economic efficiency to have the entire region share a single currency. Often larger than a country. Europe is the most modern and largest-scale example of this. |
|
|