Term
What is the Contractor's Dilemma when bidding on a project? |
|
Definition
A contractor needs to Bid High enough to make the profit, but low enough to get the job
|
|
|
Term
What is the objective of Strategic bidding? |
|
Definition
To produce "optimum bid" or "best bid" that will result in the highest possible profit
Identify optimum markup for the bid (before spending time and money to prepare a cost estimate |
|
|
Term
What are some of the benefits of Strategic bidding? |
|
Definition
- Identify the jobs which have greatest potential of profit generation
- Decide if a given job is worth bidding based on anticipated profit
- Decide on the appropriate markup for a job to reach the 'optimum bid' amount
|
|
|
Term
What is the 'Fair' profit for contractor? |
|
Definition
Typically general contractor should earn a minimum of 4%-5% on contract value
20%-25% on the capital investment |
|
|
Term
What are the groups of factors which impact the decision to bid or not to bid on a project? |
|
Definition
- Project characteristics
- Business Benefits
- Client Characteristics
- The Contract
- Project Finance
- Company Characteristics
- Firm's previous experience
- Bidding situation
- Economic Situation
- Competition
|
|
|
Term
List some characteristics of each factor group that impact a bid or no bid decision? |
|
Definition
- Project characteristics
- Size, type, location of project
- Duration, resource requirements, time of construction
- Quality of design and documentation, safety hazards
- Public exposure, stakeholders, public objection etc.
- Business Benefits
- Reputation
- Continuity of work for key personnel
- Potential of long term relationship with client
- Client Characteristics
- Relationship with Owner
- Private vs. Public
- Client's financial Capability
- Client's reputation in market
- The Contract
- Type of Contract
- Clarity of Contract documentation
- Ability of modify contract
- Ability to subcontract
- Contract Terms & Conditions
- Modification to standard contract forms
- Involvement in the design
- Project Finance
- Contract Price
- Capital requirements to start job
- Project Cash Flow
- Insurance and Bonding
- Liquidated damages
- Degree of difficulty to obtain external financing (Banks etc)
- Company Characteristics
- Availability of the resources to perform the job (Labour and Equipment)
- Need to get the work
- General Overhead
- Alignment with future vision and the core competencies
- Availability of sub-contractors
- Previous Experience
- Past experience in similar projects
- Past profit in similar jobs
- Past experience with subs
- Bidding Situation
- Bonding Capacity
- Bidding timeline
- Prequalification requirements
- Documentation requirements
- Cost of Biddding
- Economic Situation
- Labour Market
- Economic Conditions
- Risks in labour market and materials
- Risk on investment
- Competition
- Who else is bidding for this job
- Expected number of bidders
- Future projects
- Market condition (supply vs. demand of work)
|
|
|
Term
|
Definition
- Measures the effectiveness of bidding strategy
- A typical contractor (bidding out of gut feel) can have a bid efficiency in the range of 20%-30%
- Using simple bidding strategy, bid efficiency can be increased to 50% and profit can be doubled as compared to intuitive bidding
- =Actual Profit (estimated) / Maximum Profit Potential
- Maximum Profit Potential is the difference between Estimated (Construction) Cost and the lowest competitor's bid
|
|
|
Term
What does Bid Efficiency tells you? |
|
Definition
- How efficient are you right now?
- Are you becoming more (or less) efficient with time?
- How consciously deciding the markup rate will change your bid efficiency and profit?
|
|
|
Term
What is Competitive Strategy? |
|
Definition
- A technique to reach the optimum Mark-up based on historicl bid data and Project Attributes
- Information needed: Variables of Interest (or Project Attributes), such as:
- Project Size (Cost)
- Number of Bidders
- Lowest Bidder Mark up (based on your Estimated Cost) etc.
- Output: Matrix indicating optimum percentage markups based on Variables of Interest
|
|
|
Term
Other Common Methods for Competitive Strategy. |
|
Definition
- Multiple Regression analysis
- Predict a dependent variable (markup) based on one or more independent predictor variables (project size, number of competitors)
- Requires statistics software (SPSS, SAS etc.)
- Limitations: Relies on a linear relationship between variable
- Correlation analysis
- Firedman's Model
|
|
|