Shared Flashcard Set

Details

BAR EXAM
Texas Criminal Procedure and Evidence - CMR
77
Law
Professional
06/02/2013

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term
Requirements of Arrest Warrant
Definition
-Specify name of person to be arrested
-State that person is accused of particular offense and give the person adequate notice of what that offense is
-Be signed by a magistrate and give the office of that magistrate
Term
Arrests Without Warrants
Definition
-Arrests for Traffic Offenses: cop can make a custodial arrest, but not for speeding or violation of open containers law if the violator signs the citation and agrees to appear
-Entry of Residence to Make Arrest: an officer making an arrest w/o a warrant can't enter a residence unless A) person who lives in the residence consents or B) exigent circumstances
Term
When are warrantless arrests allowed?
Definition
-Suspect committed offense in front of officer
-Officer has PC to believe suspect violated a protective order
-Officer has PC to believe suspect committed a felony and is about to escape
-Officer has recovered stolen property and believes suspect stole it
-Officer has PC that suspect committed assault w/ bodily injury and there's immediate danger of further bodily injury
-Officer finds suspect in suspicious place under circumstances that reasonably show suspect is guilty of felony/disorderly conduct/etc.
-Officer has PC that suspect prevented/interfered with another person's ability to make a phone call in an emergency
-Suspect makes voluntary statement to officer that establishes PC that suspect committed a felony
Term
Writ of habeas corpus
Definition
"Show me the body" - court order to custodial person to produce person in custody and show why they're being held; used to:
-challenge amount or denial of bail
-obtain appellate review of pretrial ruling of no double jeopardy
-attack a conviction after appeal failed
Term
Requirements for Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus
Definition
-State that person is being unlawfully confined and name those confining him (including their office, if any - e.g. prison warden)
-Petition must be attached to writ under which person is detained
-Contain prayer for the writ
-Be sworn to that the allegations are true
Term
Reasons for Denial of Bail
Definition
-D is charged with capital murder and the state establishes a likelihood of conviction and the death penalty
-D is charged with a felony and has 2 prior felony convictions
-D is charged with felony while on bail for a previous felony
-D is charged with noncapital felony involving use of deadly weapon AND has a prior felony conviction
-D is charged with violent/sexual felony while on community supervision/parole
-D charged with sex crime against a child under 14 AND D violated bail condition related to safety of victim/community, OR
-D violated bail condition related to safety of victim/community

DETENTION UNDER ORDER DENYING BAIL LIMITED TO 60 DAYS
Term
Examining Trial
Definition
Felony Ds have a right to examining trial if indictment hasn't yet been returned
-Used to determine if there's PC to believe D is guilty
-But failure to establish PC not bar to prosecution
-D has right to be present and cross-examine and subpoena witnesses
Term
Statute Period of Limitations
Definition
Murder, manslaughter, leaving scene of accident that resulted in death, sexual abuse of child - NONE

Agg kidnapping with intent to abuse child younger than 17 - 20 yrs from victim's 18th birthday

Injury to a child - 10 yrs from victim's 18th birthday

Theft by fiduciary/public servant, sexual assault, injury to elderly/disabled person - 10 years

Money laundering/CC abuse - 7 years

Theft/burglary/kidnapping/abandoning or endangering a child - 5 yrs

Felonies other than those above - 3 years

Misdemeanors - 2 years
Term
Grand Jury Proceedings
Definition
-Secret - accused has no right to participate but may be allowed to
-Witnesses may invoke 5th amend
-No right to have lawyer present
-Indictment based on vote of 9/12 jurors
-ONLY way to charge felonies

-Felony D may waive his right to indictment if he's repped by counsel, waiver is written or took place in open court, and it was voluntary - then he will be charged by an information instead
Term
One offense rule
Definition
Indictment may only charge one offense, BUT several crimes can be charged in the same indictment if they're part of the same criminal episode
Term
Motion to Set Aside Indictment or Information
Definition
May be made on grounds that:
-Indictment wasn't found by at least 9 jurors
-Information wasn't based on a valid complaint
-Some person not authorized was present before the grand jury while deliberating/voting
-Grand jury was illegally impaneled OR
-Other ground authorized by law
Term
Why plead nolo contedere?
Definition
It may not be used as an admission against D in later civil litigation if it arises out of the same act as the criminal prosecution
Term
Exceptions to Double Jeopardy
Definition
-First prosecution ended in a mistrial declared for "manifest necessity"
-Mistrial requested by D
-D seeks relief for an error of law and an error in the trial is so found

CONVICTION REVERSED FOR INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE ACQUITS THE D - NO SECOND TRIAL ALLOWED!

If conviction on lesser included offense is reversed, retrial is permitted only on the lesser included offense
Term
Act and Intent
Definition
When a crime requires both a particular act and an intent, D must have required intent when he does the act constituting the crime
Term
Formal Requirements of Charging Instrument
Definition
-Name and description of accused (if wrong, D has to raise this at arraignment and judge has to correct it)
Facts for every element of offense
Enough details to give accused notice
Allege date of crime is w/i SOL and before presentment of indictment
Allege commission in county w/i jurisdiction/venue
Conclude: "AGAINST THE PEACE AND DIGNITY OF THE STATE"
Be signed by foreperson (for indictment), DA (information)
Term
Lesser included offenses
Definition
Proved by some but not all of the same facts required to prove the more serious offense, OR
Requires a less serious injury, OR
A less culpable mental state, OR
Just an attempt to commit the more serious offense

*Jury can be instructed on lesser if they could find D is NG of charged offense but guilty of lesser
Term
Raising Indictment Defects
Definition
Known as "motion to quash"

MUST BE RAISED BEFORE THE DAY OF TRIAL

Defects of substance - failure to allege elements of the crime

Defects of form - other defects

Fundamental defects - not naming the D or a really unclear description of offense

IF DENIED: can appeal ON FORM ONLY if D shows harm
Term
Curing Defects by Amendment
Definition
Allowed at any time if D doesn't object

BEFORE DAY OF TRIAL: any is allowed, unless D objects that it would allege a different offense or prejudice his rights

D is entitled to ADVANCE NOTICE of a proposed amendment
Trial judge must authorize it

IF AMENDED -- D gets 10 days extra for trial prep if requested
Term
Arraignment
Definition
Occurs in trial court
Accused enters a plea, his identity is fixed
Judge appoints counsel if indigent

PLEAS: guilty, not guilty, NOLO

D decides whether to have a trial by jury, whether to testify, and what plea to enter
Term
What warnings must the trial judge give D before he accepts a felony plea of guilty or NOLO?
Definition
Range of punishment
Limited right to appeal
Could result in deportation
Inquire as to whether there's a plea bargain

*If plea bargain is lesser than what judge imposes, D has right to withdraw plea
Term
If there's a pretrial hearing, what must the parties do?
Definition
7 days before--

-Enter any special plea
-Make challenges to the indictment
-Make motions for continuance
-Make MTV
-Make motions to suppress
-Make requests for discovery
-Raise entrapment claim
Term
Motion in limine
Definition
Pretrial motion that asks for either/both:
-Ruling on question of evidence/procedure that'll arise at trial
-Ruling that opposing counsel must alert judge before raising any matters of evidence/procedure before the jury

*DOESN'T preserve the matter for appeal
Term
Motion to suppress evidence
Definition
May be used to raise pretrial ANY argument that evidence to be offered is INADMISSIBLE

*Could wait til trial to object, but then the jury hears it

*PRESERVES FOR APPEAL
Term
Witness lists
Definition
Trial judge has discretion to order P to provide D with a witness list (but D doesn't have to!)

If P calls a W that wasn't on the list, judge has discretion to exclude/admit the testimony (looks to whether P's omission was intentional and whether D received actual notice)

EXPERT WITNESS LIST: judge has discretion to order EITHER/BOTH SIDES to provide the otherwith lists AT LEAST 20 DAYS BEFORE TRIAL
Term
Depositions
Definition
Either side can depose a W - but usually only with a verified motion for good reason (W is on his death bed and his testimony is material, etc.)

For discovery: for obtaining info for trial prep
TO preserve testimony for later use at trial
Term
What can D have access to?
Definition
His written confession
Physical evidence - drugs or blood - in order to test it
Names and testimony of grand jury Ws IF D shows "particularized need" for it
Term
Factors to Consider in Setting Bail
Definition
LASSO-

likelihood of D appearing for trial
Ability of D to make bail
Seriousness of the crime charged
Safety of V and community
Oppression - bail can't oppress
Term
What CAN'T D have access to?
Definition
State crime lab report for blood/drugs
Police reports of investigating officers (work product)
Written statements given by state Ws to police or P (also work product)
Memo from ADA to P about the case (also WP)
Term
Can informants be disclosed?
Definition
Usually no, but 2 exceptions:
-Informant provided evidence by which the state obtained evidence D claims was illegal - disclosure required to see if it's a reliable informant
-Upon a showing that informant can provide testimony to a fair degree of guilt or innocence
Term
Brady rule
Definition
P is required to disclose exculpatory and material info - if not, violates D's due process rights

*includes eyewitness IDs
Term
Competency to Stand Trial
Definition
D is incompetent if he either
1) lacks the ability to consult with counsel with a reasonable degree of understanding, or
2) lacks rational and factual understanding of the proceedings

*Can be raised by either side, or even the judge - MUST be raised by the judge if it comes to their attention

VERSUS INSANITY:
-Competency looks to D's mental state AT TRIAL, not at the time of the crime
-Insanity is "didn't know it was wrong" - competency is "don't understand my lawyer"
-Competency is a TEMPORARY, albeit not final bar to prosecution - if D regains competence at some point, he'll be tried
Term
Change of Venue
Definition
Can be sought by D because:
-Prejudice in county prevents a fair trial
-Dangerous combo of influential persons against D

Can be sought by State because:
-Combinations/influences in FAVOR of D would prevent fair trial
-Lawless conditions would prevent FT
-Life of D or W would be jeopardized by local trial
Term
Procedure for Change of Venue
Definition
File a written Motion for Change of Venue
File 3 affidavits that a fair trial can't be held in the county - one from D, two from credible residents
-Movant must present evidence @hearing of sufficient prejudice in the county
Term
How can a judge be disqualified?
Definition
Judge was victim of the crime
Judge was counsel for either side in this case
Judge is related within 3 degrees (blood OR marriage) to D or V
Bias
Term
D's presence during trial
Definition
Must be present at beginning and end of trial, but can be absent in between

Can be absent for fine-only misdemeanor if his lawyer shows up for him
Term
Joinder & Severance of Ds
Definition
Several Ds can be charged in one indictment and tried together if all charged with the same offense or different offenses arising out of th same transaction

MANDATORY SEVERANCE: D moves for severance, showing co-D has a prior conviction admissible that could prejudice D
DISCRETIONARY: judge can grant if it's prejudicial to moving D
Term
Motion for Continuance
Definition
Must be in writing, supported by a showing of good cause, and be sworn

If made AFTER trial has started:
-based on occurrence that happened after trial had begun that WASN'T anticipated and SURPRISE would prevent a fair trial

If it's to get a missing W:
-Name & residence of W
-Efforts made to secure W's presence
-Material facts D expects to prove by W

*WITHIN JUDGE'S DISCRETION
Term
Right to Counsel
Definition
Indigent D has right to counsel if charged with any felony or misdemeanor with potential jail time

Also has a right to represent himself - judge must make sure D is competent and understands the risks of doing so

RIGHT TO EFFECTIVE REPRESENTATION: lawyer must be professionally competent and conduct adequate investigation and convey to client any plea bargain offers
Term
Ake motion
Definition
For an indigent D to get an expert witness at the state's cost
Term
Right to a jury trial
Definition
Criminal D must be tried to a jury UNLESS D waives his right before trial - requires consent of P and judge too

*CANNOT be waived in capital murder cases
Term
Jury
Definition
12 in district, 6 elsewhere

Jury must communicate with judge IN WRITING and judge must also respond in writing and read to the jury in open court
Term
Jury Selection
Definition
-Swearing in a panel: qualification based on whether they are a qualified voter, have ever been convicted of theft or a felony, and if they're under indictment or accused or theft/felony

-Jury shuffle: random reseating - either D or P can request this
Term
Challenges for Cause
Definition
Grounds:

ABSOLUTELY DISQUALIFIED:
Prior conviction for theft/felony
Under formal charge for theft/felony
Insane

Not qualified to be a voter
Is a witness in the case
Served on jury in prior trial of this case
Served on indicting grand jury
Can't read or write
Biased or prejudiced for or against the accused or for or against any law applicable in this case
Term
Peremptory challenges
Definition
Each side gets:
capital murder - 15
other felonies - 10
misdemeanors in district ct - 5
misdemeanors in other ct - 3

FOR ANY REASON except race or gender
Term
Trial procedure
Definition
-Judge calls for announcements, parties announce "ready"
-P reads indictment
-D enters a plea
-P opening, D opening (or later)
-P case in chief
(motion for DV out of jury's hearing)
-D opening (or earlier)
-D case
-P rebuttal
-Judge reads charge to the jury
-Closing arguments
Term
Presenting Testimony
Definition
Both sides on application can subpoena Ws (good statewide, not just 150 mi like in civil cases) and either side can have a peace officer go get the person if they were subpoenaed but failed to appear
Term
Ways to Impeach a Witness
Definition
Character for untruthfulness (opinion and reputation evidence)
Prior convictions (final criminal conviction - inadmissible if it's pending on appeal - within 10 yrs - misdemeanor w/ moral turpitude - domestic violence, forgery, false reports to police, theft - or felony)

PRIOR INCONSISTENT STATEMENT

BIAS OR ITNEREST
Term
Expert witnesses
Definition
May testify to an opinion w/o first disclosing the facts or data on which it's based

Admissibility of scientific evidence? Look to:
-Generally accepted theory/technique
-Potential error rate
-W's qualifications/skills/knowledge
-Availability of other experts to test/evaluate the technique
-Clarity with which it can be explained in court
Term
Disclosure during trial
Definition
Party entitled to a writing if other party's W used it to refresh her memory before or during testimony
Also entitled to prior written or recorded statement
Term
Jury charge
Definition
Judge can't summarize or comment on the evidence

Judge must read to the jury before final arguments and is given a written copy

Any objections/requests must be made in writing or by dictation to court reporter BEFORE the charge is read

Should NOT define reasonable doubt
Term
Elements, exceptions and defenses
Definition
ELEMENTS: must be pleaded, jury is always instructed, burden on the state by beyond a reasonable doubt

EXCEPTIONS: must be pleaded, must be NEGATED in the charging instrument

DEFENSES: don't need to be pleaded, jury instructed only if evidence for that defense is produced, state has burden

AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES: need not be pleaded, jury instructed only if evidence produced, D has BURDEN BY PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE
Term
What can the DA not comment on during closing arguments?
Definition
-D's invocation of self-incrimination rights (to not testify, silence after Miranda warnings, silence after arrest - but CAN comment on P's silence BEFORE arrest)

Express personal opinions (I think D looks guilty)

Argue what the community demands

Attack D b/c of his lawyer
Term
What kind of evidence requires corroboration?
Definition
ACCOMPLICE TESTIMONY - D can't be convicted on their testimony unless there's corroborating evidence that connects D to the crime

UNDERCOVER INFORMER TESTIMONY

D'S OUT OF COURT CONFESSION

SEXUAL ASSAULT VICTIM'S TESTIMONY
Term
Sentencing
Definition
Ds have a right to have jury assess the punishment (in fed ct the judge does it) IF D invokes it

State CANNOT have jury decide punishment if D doesn't elect for it

All issues deemed relevant to sentencing are allowed, including D's prior record, general reputation and character
Term
Notice of extraneous offenses
Definition
D can make a pretrial request for notice of extraneous offenses that the state intends to introduce, and the state must tell D:
-date of offense
-county where it occurred
-name of victim
Term
Death Penalty Sentencing
Definition
Sentencing jury required if state seeks DP
Jury will be asked:
"Is there a probability that D will commit criminal acts of violence constituting a continuing threat?"
"Are there sufficient mitigating circumstances in warrant life imprisonment rather than death?"

If jury wants DP, judge has to do it - no discretion
Term
Judicial Confession at Sentencing
Definition
Does NOT waive any errors committed during the guilt phase - D can still win on appeal
Term
What is required for a proper application for felony probation/community supervision?
Definition
-In writing
-Sworn
-States that D hasn't been convicted of a felony
Term
Deferred adjudication
Definition
Court puts D on community supervision without finding him guilty (only applicable if it's an offense other than DWI/FWI/BWI, intoxicated assaulted, intoxication manslaughter), D enters plea of guilty or NOLO

If D successfully completes probation, the charges are dismissed

VS PROBATION: D has to be found guilty before he gets probation, but DA doesn't require this - if DA is "revoked" D can be given ANY sentence in the statutory range; if probation is revoked D can only get sentence previously assessed
Term
Interlocutory appeal on a pretrial motion
Definition
State must:
-show that jeopardy hadn't attached when the order was entered
-Appeal must be taken w/i 15 days of the order
Term
Preserving error
Definition
To preserve error in EXCLUDING EVIDENCE, counsel must make an offer of proof showing the substance of the evidence ad the record must reflect that judge rejected the offer and excluded it

To preserve error in ADMITTING EVIDENCE, counsel must make a timely objection and state specifically the ground and secure a ruling from the trial judge

IMPROPER ARGUMENT/COMMENT BY LAWYER OR JUDGE - must immediately object, seek instruction for jury to disregard, move for a mistrial and get rulings on each of these
Term
What items are required for a search warrant in Texas?
Definition
-Statement that runs in the name of "the state of Texas"
-Specification of the person, place or thing to be searched
-Specification of items to be seized
-Endorsement of the date and hour it was issued
-Signature of issuing magistrate
Term
What's Allowed in Closing Argument
Definition
Summarize the evidence and make reasonable deductions from the evidence
Term
Admonishments by judge during D's guilty plea
Definition
-Range of penalties that must be imposed
-Any recommendation by prosecution on punishment is NOT binding on the court
-Limited right to appeal after conviction on a plea of guilty
Term
Batson challenge
Definition
Claiming that a party's peremptory challenges are made on racial grounds

Have a hearing - prima facie case of racial motivation - challenged party must try to rebut prima facie showing by explaining that reasons for each strike was something other than race - moving party must show by preponderance of the evidence
Term
When must defendant be taken before a magistrate?
Definition
Without unnecessary delay - within 48 hours of arrest

If not done, D can be released on bond
Term
Duties of Magistrate at First Appearance for D
Definition
-Tell D the charges
-Tell D his rights to retain counsel and to an examining trial
-Warn D of Miranda and 6A rights
-Set bail
-Determine whether PC exists
Term
Denial of Bail
Definition
Possible when D is being prosecuted for CAPITAL MURDER or for certain prosecutions for NONCAPITAL FELONIES

State must file motion in district court
Any order denying bail must issue within 7 days of D's arrest
Term
Reduction of Bail
Definition
File application for writ of habeas corpus
At hearing, introduce evidence showing
-Bail was excessive
-D can't meet bail set
-This is what D can meet
Term
Trial court factors in determining bail
Definition
LASSO

Likelihood of D appearing for trial
Ability of D to make bail
Seriousness of the crime charged
Future safety of victim/community
Oppression - bail isn't used for this
Term
Examining Trial
Definition
Pretrial hearing before a magistrate - requires State to produce evidence showing PC to believe D is guilty of the crime
Term
D's Rights at Examining Trial
Definition
-Right to present
-Right to be represented by counsel
-Have rules of evidence applied
-Cross-examine State witnesses
-Subpoena & present D witnesses
Term
Information vs. Indictment
Definition
Information: pleading filed by State charging D with criminal offense - ONLY needs to be approved & signed by the Prosecutor

INDICTMENT: Must be approved by a grand jury and signed by the foreperson
Term
Who selects the people who will serve on the grand jury?
Definition
Either by grand jury commissioners appointed by the district judge or just like trial jurors are picked for civil cases
Term
How can D challenge the composition of the grand jury?
Definition
Texas CCP requires commissioners to choose a broad cross section of grand jurors (race, sex, age) - D should raise the matter during GJ selection by a CHALLENGE TO THE ARRAY
Term
D's presence at grand jury proceedings
Definition
-Can be compelled to appear by subpoena - can't be compelled to answer questions if they're self-incriminating

-He will be a suspect witness - so before questioning he must be warned of the offense of which he's suspected, the county in which it occurred and the time it occurred at - ALL QUESTIONS AND TESTIMONY MUST BE RECORDED
Term
Warning for Grand Jury Subpoena
Definition
D must be warned that
-Testimony will be under oath
-False answer to a material question subjects him to prosecution for perjury
-He can refuse to answer incriminating Q's
-He has a right to have counsel appointed if he can't afford one
-Right to counsel outside the room
-His testimony can be used against him
Supporting users have an ad free experience!